Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Re: [papercreters] Re: Floor Question for Ron and Doris



Ken Kern was killed when an experimental cave with a pvc roof collapsed, hardly a house. Ken did a lot of experimental things along this line which most people do not do. Certainly I wouldn't. His wife begged him not to spend the night in the cave as it had rained a lot and the roof was saturated. I still stand by my statement that no one was killed when a house collapsed because houses don't collapse except in floods, tornadoes and hurricanes in which case most are built to code. I am certainly not belittling Ron and Doris' house, only trying to make a point that people who are exploring the possibilities of pc construction in this forum are going to be in for a rude awakening when they try to run this by the code people.  --- On Tue, 5/31/11, Spaceman <Spaceman@starship-enterprises.net> wrote:

From: Spaceman <Spaceman@starship-enterprises.net>
Subject: Re: [papercreters] Re: Floor Question for Ron and Doris
To: papercreters@yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, May 31, 2011, 10:14 AM

 
Google Ken Kern and read about a home collapsing in the night and killing the occupant.

It is possible to build "such a structure within areas where codes are enforced now" if it is well designed and sturdily built. As has been mentioned, if you have the money to hire an engineer you can have plans approved, and build under the legal umbrella. There is more than one company in the pc business that I know of. One is outside Silver City NM, the other is in west Texas. All reports are that their products are very affordable. Neither of them would meet the definition of "big business".

Codes in NM are liberal and have some allowance for DIY. For instance both adobe and rammed earth are in the code. The community of earthships near Tres Piedras is a good example of alternative building being allowed, though there was the usual politics causing unnecessary infrastructure to meet subdivision rules. There are vast areas in the SW US that have no codes enforced, land that you can buy for a few hundred dollars an acre. There are several folks on this list who have done what you say is impossible. Every day you make a choice about where and how you live. It is a lot easier to sit and imagine why things won't work than it is to go try them. Life is full of surprises and things don't always conform to your imagination.

The first known, and most strict, building code in history.
"Should a mason build a home of brick or of stone, and should that home collapse and injure or kill any occupant, the responsible mason shall be slain and his blood and bones built into the repairs of the said stone or brick building."
-Law code of Hammurabi engraved on Babylonian Stele, 1750 b.c.

spaceman  All opinions expressed or implied are subject to change without notice upon receipt of new information.  
On 5/31/2011 7:15 AM, Donald Miller wrote:
You mention that building codes probably save lives. That is the common argument that the code people use and I find it to be very untruthful. I challenge anyone to show documented proof of a home not built to code falling over onto a neighbor's lot, collapsing in the night and killing the occupants or whatever. Houses may sag, foundations will crack and sheetrock break, but, give me a break, they just dont' collapse in a heap. You are more likely to have that happen to a commercially built and "engineered " commercial structure than in someone's do it yourself house. And, Ron and Doris, I commend you on your beautiful addition to your home. The point I am making is that it is not possible to build such a structure within areas where codes are enforced now matter how well designed and sturdily built. And if big companies ever get in the PC business, which I doubt very much, the product will be as expensive  as standard building materials, again negating the promise of papercrete as an affordable way for people of limitied means to build a home.


__._,_.___


Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch to Fully Featured
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe

__,_._,___